Who Has Better Test Average: Joe Root or Kane Williamson?
When discussing the greatest Test batters of the modern era, two names consistently dominate the conversation—Joe Root and Kane Williamson. Both have been pillars of their respective teams for over a decade, producing match-winning performances across continents.
But when it comes to one of the most important batting metrics in cricket—Test batting average—who comes out on top?
The answer isn’t as straightforward as it appears.
Quick Answer
| Category | Joe Root | Kane Williamson |
|---|---|---|
| Matches | 160+ | 110+ |
| Runs | 14,000+ | 9,500+ |
| Test Average | ≈51 | ≈55 |
| Hundreds | 38+ | 33+ |
| Double Hundreds | 7 | 6 |
| Highest Score | 262 | 251 |
| Verdict | More runs & longevity | Better average |
Winner in Test Average: Kane Williamson
Winner in Overall Test Career: Joe Root
Joe Root’s Test Career



Joe Root has been England’s batting backbone since making his Test debut in 2012.
His biggest strengths include:
- Exceptional consistency
- Ability to bat long innings
- Excellent technique against pace
- Success in all conditions
- Huge volume of runs
Root has played significantly more Test matches than Williamson, making his sustained average above 50 even more remarkable.
Root’s Key Test Stats
- Runs: 14,000+
- Average: Around 51
- Hundreds: 38+
- Fifties: 65+
- Highest Score: 262
- Double Hundreds: 7
Root is among the highest run-scorers in Test history and continues to climb the all-time rankings.
Also Read | Steve Smith vs Joe Root Comparison

Kane Williamson’s Test Career



Kane Williamson made his Test debut in 2010 and quickly established himself as New Zealand’s greatest batter.
He is known for:
- Classical batting technique
- Outstanding patience
- Excellent shot selection
- Ability to dominate both pace and spin
- Exceptional conversion rate
Despite playing far fewer Tests than Root, Williamson has maintained an elite batting average throughout his career.
Williamson’s Key Test Stats
- Runs: 9,500+
- Average: Around 55
- Hundreds: 33+
- Highest Score: 251
- Double Hundreds: 6
Head-to-Head Comparison
| Statistic | Joe Root | Kane Williamson | Better |
|---|---|---|---|
| Test Average | ~51 | ~55 | ✅ Williamson |
| Runs | 14,000+ | 9,500+ | ✅ Root |
| Matches | 160+ | 110+ | ✅ Root |
| Hundreds | 38+ | 33+ | ✅ Root |
| Double Hundreds | 7 | 6 | ✅ Root |
| Highest Score | 262 | 251 | ✅ Root |
| Longevity | Outstanding | Excellent | ✅ Root |
| Average Consistency | Excellent | Elite | ✅ Williamson |
Why Does Williamson Have the Better Average?
Several factors contribute to Williamson’s superior average.
1. Fewer Career Slumps
Williamson has experienced fewer prolonged lean patches than Root.
2. Better Conversion
He converts starts into centuries more frequently.
3. Controlled Shot Selection
Williamson’s disciplined approach reduces dismissals after getting set.
4. Home Dominance
New Zealand conditions suit his technical game, where he has accumulated numerous big scores.
Why Root Has More Runs
Root has several advantages that explain his superior aggregate.
More Matches
England plays more Test cricket than New Zealand.
Better Availability
Root has rarely missed series due to injuries.
Longevity
He has been a regular in England’s Test side for well over a decade.
Batting Workload
England often plays 12–15 Tests annually, compared to New Zealand’s lighter schedule.
Away Record Comparison
Away performances often separate great players from legends.
Joe Root
- Hundreds in Australia
- Hundreds in India
- Hundreds in Sri Lanka
- Hundreds in South Africa
- Hundreds in New Zealand
Root has scored Test centuries in nearly every major cricketing nation.
Kane Williamson
Williamson has also enjoyed overseas success, particularly in:
However, his away average is slightly lower than his exceptional home record.
Performance Against Top Teams
Joe Root
Excellent record against:
- Australia
- India
- South Africa
- Pakistan
- New Zealand
Kane Williamson
Outstanding against:
- Pakistan
- Sri Lanka
- West Indies
- Bangladesh
He has also produced memorable performances against England and Australia.
Batting Style Comparison
| Attribute | Joe Root | Kane Williamson |
|---|---|---|
| Technique | 9.5/10 | 10/10 |
| Cover Drive | Excellent | Excellent |
| Footwork vs Spin | Outstanding | Excellent |
| Patience | Excellent | Elite |
| Adaptability | Excellent | Excellent |
| Stroke Range | Wider | Classical |
| Consistency | Excellent | Elite |
Who Performs Better Under Pressure?
Joe Root
- Frequently rescues England from difficult situations.
- Has scored numerous fourth-innings centuries.
- Often carries the batting lineup.
Kane Williamson
- Calm under pressure.
- Key performer in close contests.
- Anchors New Zealand’s innings with composure.
Both thrive under pressure, though Root has faced a heavier workload due to England’s extensive Test schedule.
Who Has Better Longevity?
This category clearly favors Joe Root.
Reasons include:
- More Test matches
- More innings
- More runs
- Longer uninterrupted career
- Sustained average above 50 over a larger sample size
Career Statistics Comparison
| Statistic | Joe Root | Kane Williamson | Advantage |
|---|---|---|---|
| Test Debut | 2012 | 2010 | Williamson |
| Matches | 160+ | 110 | Root |
| Innings | 290+ | 190+ | Root |
| Runs | 14,000+ | 9,500+ | Root |
| Batting Average | ≈51 | ≈55 | Williamson |
| Hundreds | 38+ | 33 | Root |
| Fifties | 65+ | 37+ | Root |
| Double Hundreds | 7 | 6 | Root |
| Highest Score | 262 | 251 | Root |
| 50+ Scores | 100+ | 70+ | Root |
| Ducks | 15+ | 10+ | Williamson |
| Not Outs | 24+ | 18+ | Root |
Statistics updated through August 2026.
Home vs Away Record
One criticism often directed at Kane Williamson is that his outstanding overall average is heavily boosted by his exceptional home record.
| Venue | Joe Root | Kane Williamson |
|---|---|---|
| Home Average | ~56 | 64+ |
| Away Average | 46+ | ~46 |
| Neutral Venues | 44+ | 49+ |
Analysis
- Williamson averages over 64 at home, among the highest in Test history.
- Root’s home average is lower but remains outstanding.
- Away from home, the gap almost disappears, with both averaging in the mid-40s.
Century Conversion Rate
One of the best measures of a batter is how often they convert fifties into hundreds.
| Statistic | Root | Williamson |
|---|---|---|
| Hundreds | 38+ | 33 |
| Fifties | 65+ | 37+ |
| Total 50+ Scores | 103+ | 70+ |
| Century Conversion | ≈37% | ≈47% |
Winner: Kane Williamson
Williamson converts nearly one in every two 50-plus scores into a century, placing him among the elite finishers in Test cricket.
Runs per Match
| Player | Runs per Test |
|---|---|
| Joe Root | 87+ |
| Kane Williamson | 86+ |
Despite their different careers, both average nearly the same number of runs per Test.
Hundreds Against Top Nations
| Opposition | Root | Williamson |
|---|---|---|
| Australia | 8+ | 5+ |
| India | 4+ | 3+ |
| South Africa | 4+ | 2+ |
| Pakistan | 4+ | 6+ |
| New Zealand/England | N/A | N/A |
Root has scored centuries against every major Test nation, showcasing his adaptability across conditions.
Away Centuries
| Country | Joe Root | Kane Williamson |
|---|---|---|
| Australia | ✅ | ✅ |
| India | ✅ | ❌ |
| South Africa | ✅ | ✅ |
| Sri Lanka | ✅ | ✅ |
| Pakistan/UAE | ✅ | ✅ |
| New Zealand/England | ✅ | ✅ |
Root has been successful in virtually every major Test-playing nation.
Performance While Chasing
Williamson has built a remarkable reputation in fourth-innings batting.
| Statistic | Joe Root | Kane Williamson |
|---|---|---|
| Fourth Innings Average | ~38 | 55+ |
| Fourth Innings Hundreds | 2 | 5 |
This is one of Williamson’s biggest statistical advantages over Root.
Performance Since 2020
Both players entered another golden phase after 2020.
| Player | Runs | Average | Hundreds |
|---|---|---|---|
| Joe Root | 6,500+ | 54+ | 24 |
| Kane Williamson | 3,000+ | 62+ | 12 |
Although Root has scored more than twice as many runs due to playing far more Tests, Williamson has maintained the higher batting average.
Batting in Winning Causes
| Player | Average in Wins |
|---|---|
| Joe Root | 60+ |
| Kane Williamson | 65+ |
Both players elevate their performances in victories, with Williamson holding a slight statistical edge.
Batting Against the New Ball
| Metric | Joe Root | Kane Williamson |
|---|---|---|
| Technique | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ |
| Against Swing | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐⭐☆ |
| Against Spin | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ |
| Defensive Technique | ⭐⭐⭐⭐☆ | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ |
| Stroke Variety | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐⭐☆ |
ICC Test Rankings
| Achievement | Root | Williamson |
|---|---|---|
| Reached No.1 Ranking | ✅ | ✅ |
| Years Among Top 5 | 10+ | 10+ |
| World Test Championship Winner | ❌ | ✅ (2021) |
Williamson’s greatest team achievement remains leading New Zealand to the inaugural ICC World Test Championship title.
Records Comparison
Joe Root
- England’s highest Test run-scorer.
- One of the top five Test run-scorers in history.
- Most Test centuries by an England batter.
- Most Test runs among the modern “Fab Four.”
Kane Williamson
- New Zealand’s leading Test run-scorer.
- Highest Test average among New Zealand batters with 5,000+ runs.
- Five fourth-innings Test centuries (joint record).
- Led New Zealand to the World Test Championship title.
Final Verdict
If the only question is:
Who has the better Test batting average?
🏆 Winner: Kane Williamson
His average of approximately 55 is comfortably ahead of Joe Root’s 51, making him statistically superior in this specific metric.
However, if the debate expands to overall Test career, the picture changes.
Joe Root’s extraordinary run tally, remarkable longevity, consistent performances across all conditions, and success over a much larger number of matches make him one of the greatest Test batters of all time.
Conclusion
Both players are modern-day legends, but they excel in different ways.
- Choose Kane Williamson if batting average is your primary measure of greatness.
- Choose Joe Root if you value longevity, consistency, total runs, and sustained excellence across a longer career.
In the end, cricket fans are fortunate to have witnessed two technically brilliant batters who have defined Test cricket for more than a decade.
Answer in one line: Kane Williamson has the better Test batting average, while Joe Root has the more accomplished overall Test career.
Player Comparison
Related Pages
Women’s Team Records
Women’s Batting Records
- Most Runs in Women’s Cricket
- Most Test Centuries
- Highest Individual Women’s Test Scores
- Women’s Batting Rankings
Women’s World Cup Records
- Women’s World Cup Winners
- Women’s World Cup Records
- Women’s T20 World Cup Records






Leave a Reply